Gore or Barlow?
Kwame Harris, Anthony Clement, David Baas, Adam Snyder, Justin Smiley and Eric Heitmann.
You probably sound a lot like an owl right now.
Those guys you’ve probably never heard of were “blocking” for 49er running backs Kevan Barlow and Frank Gore last season. This season the 49ers offensive line will feature 2002 pro bowler Jeremy Newberry (returning from injury), 10-time pro bowler Larry Allen (free agent) and Jonas Jennings (returning from injury) who has the potential to end up in Hawaii when healthy.
While the new faces on the O-line won’t be enough to get the 49ers into the playoffs this season, stealing Gore or Barlow late in drafts could help you make you make a postseason run. The revamped offensive line combined with the fact that the Niners clearly didn’t trust quarterback Alex Smith last season are good reasons to suspect sharply improved numbers from San Francisco’s backfield.
But who will get the bulk of the touches in 2006? Gore or Barlow?
Most publications lean toward Gore and my Summer drafts reflect those opinions, but if you are a gambling man like myself, hold off on Gore (usually a 4th-5th round selection) and snag Barlow with a pick sometime between rounds eight and 10.
In 2003, Barlow looked nasty rushing for 1,024 yards (5.1 YPC) and seven t
ouchdowns. In the last two seasons Barlow hasn’t rushed for more than 3.4 yards a touch, but it’s really a mystery why.
There was no big injury. Age isn’t an issue (he’s 27). Despite the label “starter” Barlow has averaged the same amount of carries the past two years as he did in 2003 so it wasn’t the work load. Circumstantial evidence suggests that Barlow’s decline has more to do with is supporting cast (or lack thereof) by the bay in recent years.
In 2006, Barlow will actually have players around him so defenses won’t be able to key on him like they did they past two seasons. Legitimate receiving threats in Antonio Bryant (free agent), Vernon Davis (6th overall pick in this season’s draft), and Eric Johnson (returning from injury) should do the trick.
Johnson quietly caught 82 passes in 2004 and he will be the 49ers second option at tight end behind Davis, but they should see plenty of time on the field together. The 25-year-old Bryant is coming off a career year, and regardless of what you may have read, he’s an upgrade from Brandon Lloyd.
Guys like Amani Toomer, Mark Clayton and Greg Jones will get picked ahead of Barlow at your draft so don’t be afraid to pull the trigger. If I’m right, you’ll thank me. If I’m wrong you know where to find me.